by Winebounty Team| Nov 12, 2023

When you think of Thanksgiving, it’s hard not to visualize a table laden with turkey, stuffing, cranberry sauce, sweet potatoes, and a medley of autumnal vegetables. It’s a meal that embodies warmth, celebration, and the richness of the season’s harvest. And nestled among the bounty, the quintessential bottle of wine – a component as vital as the turkey itself (at least for us!). In fact, the versatility of wine can elevate the diverse spread of a Thanksgiving dinner into a harmonious gastronomic symphony.

Nevertheless, the vast world of wine, with its wide-ranging spectrum of flavors and styles can sometimes baffle even the most seasoned grape enthusiasts. Amid this cornucopia of choice, it’s easy to step into unfamiliar territories, stumbling upon wines that may not be quite suited to your Thanksgiving banquet. While the spirit of experimentation should never be curbed, the traditional fall meal we all adore tends to flourish best when paired thoughtfully. Therefore, in the spirit of ensuring the optimal enjoyment of food and wine, we present five wines you might reconsider before placing them beside the cranberry sauce and gravy boat.

  1. Sweet Rosé: While Rosé is often a versatile, widely-loved choice, the sweeter variants can be a letdown at Thanksgiving. The residual sugar in sweet Rosés clashes with the myriad of flavors on the plate, from the succulent roasted turkey to the tart cranberry sauce. Instead, try a dry Rosé, which has the acidity and bright fruit flavors to balance your taste buds’ dance between sweet, salty, and savory dishes.

  2. Oaky, Buttery Chardonnay: The traditional heavily oaked, butter-laden Chardonnay can overpower your palates at the Thanksgiving dinner. Its strong vanilla and buttery flavors could overlap with the rich, buttery dishes on the table, leading to a monotonous taste experience. Opt for an unoaked Chardonnay or a vibrant Sauvignon Blanc for a refreshing counterpoint to heavy dishes.

  3. High-Tannin Red Wines: Full-bodied reds like Cabernet Sauvignon, Tannat, or Nebbiolo, although excellent in other circumstances, can dominate over the delicacy of the Thanksgiving meal. The high tannins and heavy structure can cause the turkey and other mild ingredients to taste bland. Lighter reds like Pinot Noir, Beaujolais, or Grenache make friendlier companions to this festive meal.

  4. Desert Wines: Port, ice wine, Sauternes, and other dessert wines may seem like a tempting finale to your meal. However, keep in mind they should be paired with desserts of matching sweetness levels. Overly sweet wines can turn the pumpkin pie or pecan tart into a sugar overload, spoiling the finale of your meal. A late-harvest Riesling or a Moscato d’Asti can offer a delicate balance of sweetness and acidity.

  5. Intensely Minerally Wines: Wines with a strong mineral profile, like some Chablis or Muscadet, could risk clashing with the cornucopia of flavors at a Thanksgiving feast. Their steely, sharply-defined character and flinty mineral note often require a simple, seafood-oriented pairing rather than a complex, multi-ingredient meal.

In the end, choosing a wine that both caters to your guests’ varying palates while complementing the diverse elements of your Thanksgiving meal can create an unparalleled dining experience. And let’s not forget, the essence of Thanksgiving lies in the celebration of this joyous season, the company you keep, and the memories that you make – and that pairing is perfect with any meal or wine.

This page contains affiliate links.  We receive a small compensation when you purchase through affiliate links.  While clicking these links won’t cost you a cent, it will help us keep the lights on and buy more wine.  To find out more, click here.